Dylan Crews and Paul Skenes are both incredible players. Does one make more sense for the Pirates at first overall in the MLB draft?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e9236/e923613583b1409c551ea658bd060cbb6db35e96" alt=""
Dylan Crews and Paul Skenes are both incredible players. Does one make more sense for the Pirates at first overall in the MLB draft?